Skip to main content

Which grade are you exploring?

We'll open that grade's lessons. You can switch any time on the lessons page.

Not sure? Find your child's level with the free Grade Check

Grade 5 writing · Opinion and persuasion

Comics: Mixed Opinion Writing Review

Identify an opinion, choose relevant support, and write a persuasive comic speech bubble.

  • Grade: Grade 5
  • Standard: W.5.1.a, W.5.1.b
  • Questions: 14 questions: 13 multiple-choice items and 1 written speech bubble
  • Pages: 2 worksheet pages and a 2-page answer key

Practice opinions, reasons, and evidence through comic-style panels5

Each one practices the same skill a different way, with its own answer key.

Worksheets on the skills that build on this one.

About this worksheet

This Grade 5 mixed review uses comic-panel dialogue about adding comics to a class library. Learners identify an opinion, choose strong reasons and details, select a respectful reply to a concern, and write one persuasive speech bubble. The answer key marks choices and gives a sample response. The questions practice Common Core W.5.1.a and W.5.1.b.

Aligned to W.5.1.a and W.5.1.b

How do the comic panels frame the writing task?

Thirteen multiple-choice questions use a class-library discussion about adding comics. Learners identify an opinion, choose relevant reasons and details, and select a respectful response. The final question asks them to write a speech bubble supporting the proposal.

  • Questions 1–6: identify an opinion, reason, and argument order
  • Questions 7–13: select useful support, endings, and respectful replies
  • Question 14: write a speech bubble with an opinion and reason
  • Answer key includes a sample response

What makes a reason persuasive?

A reason explains why an opinion makes sense. A useful detail gives a reader something specific to consider, such as a class poll result. Learners select relevant support and apply the idea in their own speech bubble.

Worked example from Part A
  1. 1Opinion: Add library comics.
  2. 2Reason: Pictures help readers.
  3. 3Detail: A poll found 18 students chose comics.

How can a response address a concern?

A respectful reply recognizes a concern and suggests a workable next step. The final speech bubble should state a clear opinion and a reason that supports adding comics.

How to use this worksheet at home or in class

  1. 1Read each short panel or prompt before choosing.
  2. 2For Part A, find the sentence that states a belief or proposed change.
  3. 3Ask whether the reason explains the opinion and whether the detail supports it.
  4. 4For Part B, choose a relevant detail or respectful reply.
  5. 5Use the answer key to review why each selected line fits.

Common mistakes and quick fixes

The mistake

Treating a fact as an opinion because it mentions the library.

The fix

Ask whether the sentence can be checked or whether it states what should happen.

The mistake

Adding a reason that does not explain the opinion.

The fix

Use “because” and check that the following idea tells why.

The mistake

Replying to a concern with an insult or dismissal.

The fix

Acknowledge the concern and offer a respectful solution.

Common Core alignment

This page practices the listed Common Core skill through the questions and responses on the sheet.

W.5.1.aCommon Core · Grade 5

State a clear opinion and group ideas to support it.

On this sheet: Questions in Parts A and B ask learners to identify an opinion and select reasons, details, and conclusions that support it.

Show the official wording
Introduce a topic or text clearly, state an opinion, and create an organizational structure in which ideas are logically grouped to support the writer’s purpose.
W.5.1.a on the standards site
W.5.1.bCommon Core · Grade 5

Support an opinion with ordered reasons and specific details.

On this sheet: Questions 2–4 and 6–10 select reasons, relevant evidence, and an ordered argument; question 14 asks learners to write an opinion with a reason.

Show the official wording
Provide logically ordered reasons that are supported by facts and details.
W.5.1.b on the standards site

What to practice next

Make more practice

Further reading

Questions parents and teachers ask

What does this Grade 5 comics worksheet practice?

Learners work through a class-library discussion about adding comics. The multiple-choice questions ask them to identify an opinion, choose relevant reasons and details, and consider a respectful response to a concern. The final item asks them to write a comic speech bubble using the same argument skills.

What makes a reason useful in an opinion argument?

A useful reason explains why the writer’s opinion makes sense. A detail can make that reason more specific, such as a poll showing that 18 students chose comics. Learners compare possible reasons and evidence, then write one short bubble that states an opinion and a reason.

How does the worksheet use comics?

The prompts frame the class-library discussion as comic-panel dialogue, and the final response is a speech bubble the learner writes. The printable template presents the dialogue in text so the argument choices remain easy to read. The questions focus on opinions, relevant support, and a respectful reply.

How many questions and pages are included?

There are 14 questions: thirteen multiple-choice items and one written response. The worksheet has two pages, followed by a two-page answer key. The final response has a sample answer; another bubble is acceptable if it gives a clear opinion and a relevant reason.

What should a respectful reply do?

A respectful reply recognizes a concern and offers a workable idea. For shelf space, “Try one small shelf” addresses the concern while keeping the proposal to add comics. Learners can use that example when writing the final speech bubble and when comparing possible responses.