Skip to main content

Which grade are you exploring?

We'll open that grade's lessons. You can switch any time on the lessons page.

Not sure? Find your child's level with the free Grade Check

Grade 5 writing · Opinions, reasons and evidence

Snacktime Opinion Writing: Recognize the Skill

Identify persuasive writing parts in snacktime examples, choose useful support, and write two connected responses.

  • Grade: Grade 5
  • Standard: CCSS W.5.1c
  • Questions: 14: 12 multiple choice and 2 written responses
  • Pages: 2 worksheet pages and 2 answer key pages

More Grade 5 persuasive writing topics5

Each one practices the same skill a different way, with its own answer key.

Worksheets on the skills that build on this one.

GardenRecognize the SkillGrade 5Open
GardenGuided CompletionGrade 5Open
GardenSentence PracticeGrade 5Open
GardenEdit and CorrectGrade 5Open
ComicsRecognize the SkillGrade 5Open
ComicsGuided CompletionGrade 5Open
ComicsSentence PracticeGrade 5Open
ComicsEdit and CorrectGrade 5Open
WeekendsRecognize the SkillGrade 5Open
WeekendsGuided CompletionGrade 5Open
WeekendsSentence PracticeGrade 5Open
WeekendsEdit and CorrectGrade 5Open

About this worksheet

This free Grade 5 worksheet uses a familiar decision, how to organize classroom snacktime, to practice recognizing persuasive writing. Students identify claims, reasons and evidence in six examples, identify audience and purpose in two more, then choose supporting details and linking words in four more. Two short written responses ask them to explain evidence and connect an opinion to a reason. The practice supports Common Core W.5.1c through links between opinions and reasons. All classroom observations and counts are invented examples for this activity. A separate answer key includes model responses.

Aligned to W.5.1c

What does each persuasive writing part do?

A claim names the choice a writer wants the reader to make. A reason gives a benefit or explanation for that choice. Evidence gives something specific to check, such as an observation or a count. Ask what job a sentence does in the argument before choosing a label.

Part A has eight snacktime examples. Questions 3 and 6 give a cleanup time and a count of basket users, making them examples of evidence. The directions label the classroom examples as made up. The last two questions identify the intended reader and the purpose of a request.

How can students recognize evidence that fits?

Evidence needs to support the particular reason. A detail about apple color does not show that sliced apples are easy to share. A count of slices does. In Part B, students must choose a useful detail, not just any statement about food.

Worked example: question 9
  1. 1Reason: Sliced apples are easy to share.
  2. 2Detail: Each apple had 8 slices.
  3. 3Why it fits: The slices can be divided among students.
  4. 4The color or shape of a whole apple does not explain sharing.

How do the last two questions turn recognition into writing?

Part C asks students to explain how a two-minute cleanup supports a short snack break, then join a request for water to the reason that water can refill reusable bottles. These responses connect the chosen support to the opinion.

Use the model answers to check the relationship between ideas. Accept different wording when it states the reason clearly and uses the supplied detail accurately.

How to use this worksheet

  1. 1Read the first claim aloud and ask what change the writer wants.
  2. 2Complete Part A: name each writing part, then identify the audience and purpose of the last two requests.
  3. 3For questions 9 and 10, reread the reason before judging each detail.
  4. 4Read the linking-word choices in the whole sentence to check their meaning.
  5. 5Check the two written responses for a clear connection to the supplied detail or reason.

Common mistakes and helpful fixes

The mistake

Calling every sentence about snacks a claim.

The fix

Ask what action the sentence recommends. A report of a timed trial supplies evidence instead.

The mistake

Choosing a true-sounding detail that does not support the reason.

The fix

Match the detail to the exact reason: slices help sharing, while apple color does not.

The mistake

Using although when the second idea gives a reason.

The fix

Read both ideas with because. Use a reason link when the second idea supports the first.

Common Core alignment

W.5.1cCommon Core · Grade 5

Connect a snacktime opinion to its reason with a linking word or phrase.

On this sheet: Questions 11, 12 and 14 practice connections using because and For this reason.

Show the official wording
Link opinion and reasons using words, phrases, and clauses (e.g., consequently, specifically).
W.5.1c on the standards site

What to practice next

Make more practice

Further reading

Questions parents and teachers ask

What is included in the Snacktime worksheet?

The worksheet has fourteen questions in three parts: eight recognition questions, four choices about support and connections, and two written responses. Students work with claims, reasons and evidence about classroom snack routines. A separate answer key marks the choices and gives sample sentences for the writing tasks.

Are the classroom trial details real research?

No, the classroom details are invented practice examples, as the worksheet directions explain. Students use them to learn what evidence does in an argument. The two-minute cleanup and the count of twenty-four basket users are details to evaluate within the activity, not findings about classrooms generally.

Why is “Each apple had 8 slices” the best detail?

It supports the stated reason that sliced apples are easy to share. Eight slices can be divided among students, so the detail connects to sharing. The other choices describe an apple’s color or movement, which does not explain why slicing makes it easier to share.

Must my child copy the model answers in Part C?

No, different wording is welcome when the connection is clear. Question 13 should explain why a two-minute cleanup helps a short break work. Question 14 should request water and connect that request to refilling reusable bottles, using because. Check the ideas before editing spelling or punctuation.

How can we use this after the answers are checked?

Ask your child to propose a snacktime routine and give one reason for it. Then ask what observation would help support that reason, such as timing cleanup or counting supplies. Keep invented examples clearly labeled, and use actual observations if your child later writes a real classroom proposal.