About this worksheet
This free printable worksheet gives Grade 5 students twelve reasoning tasks about subtracting mixed numbers with like denominators. Six missing-number equations lead into choices about errors, renaming, comparisons, and an addition check. Students finish with two explanations about the size of a difference and a regrouping error. Common Core 4.NF.B.3.c connects this work to equivalent fractions and the relationship between addition and subtraction. The answer key provides numerical answers, correct choices, and concise models for the explanations. Students should already be comfortable naming one whole as a fraction.
Aligned to 4.NF.B.3.c
How does renaming preserve the starting amount?
A whole can be traded for enough fraction pieces to make one whole. With sixths, one whole becomes 6/6. Reducing the whole-number part by one and adding six sixths keeps the total unchanged.
Question 12 makes this balance explicit. Leo adds eight eighths but leaves four wholes in place, so his new amount is too large. Students explain why the correct renamed form has three wholes.
- 14 1/6 = 3 7/6
- 23 7/6 − 2 5/6 = 1 2/6
- 31 2/6 = 1 1/3
- 4Check: 2 5/6 + 1 1/3 = 4 1/6
Can students compare differences without subtracting?
Yes. In question 9, both expressions start with 4 5/8. The first takes away 2 1/8 and the second takes away 2 3/8. Taking away the smaller amount leaves more, so the first difference is greater.
Question 11 uses a nearby subtraction fact to explain why a difference is less than three. A convincing answer can compare starting amounts, use regrouping, or include an exact calculation.
How can addition help with a missing number?
For a missing starting amount, add the known subtrahend and difference. For a missing amount taken away, subtract the known difference from the starting amount. Then put the result into the original equation to check it.
For question 3, adding 1 3/4 and 2 1/4 gives a starting amount of 4. Subtract 1 3/4 from 4 to confirm that the difference is 2 1/4.
How to use this worksheet
- 1Review one whole as sixths, eighths, or fourths before starting.
- 2Have students solve Part A, checking each missing number in its original equation.
- 3In Part B, ask for an oral reason for each choice before checking the key.
- 4Read the two explanation prompts carefully and write a numerical reason or a clear sentence.
- 5Check the missing starting amount in question 3 by adding the subtrahend and difference.
- 6Revisit each incorrect choice and explain what makes the corrected statement true.
Mistakes to discuss
The mistake
Subtracting the smaller numerator from the larger regardless of order.
The fix
Keep the subtraction order; regroup the first mixed number when its fraction part is too small.
The mistake
Adding a denominator to the numerator without reducing the whole number.
The fix
Trade one whole, so the whole-number part must drop by one.
The mistake
Adding to find a missing amount taken away.
The fix
Use starting amount minus amount left, then check by adding the removed amount back.
Common Core alignment
Rename mixed numbers and use addition to check subtraction with like denominators.
On this sheet: Students regroup, find missing mixed numbers, compare differences, and explain subtraction errors.
Show the official wordingHide the official wording
Add and subtract mixed numbers with like denominators, e.g., by replacing each mixed number with an equivalent fraction, and/or by using properties of operations and the relationship between addition and subtraction.
What to practice next
Make more practice
Further reading
Questions parents and teachers ask
What makes this sheet a reasoning challenge?
Students must do more than compute differences. They find missing starting or removed amounts, judge a renamed mixed number, choose an addition check, compare two expressions, and explain errors. The two written responses make their reasoning visible so an adult can discuss the method as well as the answer.
Do all the questions require regrouping?
No, the sheet includes several kinds of reasoning, and students should decide when regrouping is useful. Question 1 needs it because one sixth is smaller than five sixths. Question 9 can be answered by comparing the amounts taken away, with no exact subtraction required at all.
How should students explain question 11?
A clear explanation shows why the difference is below three. One approach compares 5 2/7 with 5 5/7: subtracting 2 5/7 from the larger starting amount gives exactly three. Since the actual starting amount is smaller, its difference must be smaller too. Equivalent numerical reasoning is acceptable.
Should answers be simplified?
Yes, simplify the missing numbers in Part A. In question 1, one and two sixths becomes one and one third. Part B also uses regrouped forms such as four and eight sixths; keep those forms when the question asks you to recognize an equivalent amount.
How can the answer key support discussion?
Use the key after students explain their choices and show their working. For written responses, compare the mathematical reason rather than requiring the exact wording. If a result differs, add the proposed difference to the amount taken away and see whether it recreates the original starting amount.














