Skip to main content

Which grade are you exploring?

We'll open that grade's lessons. You can switch any time on the lessons page.

Not sure? Find your child's level with the free Grade Check

Grade 5 writing · Fair Replies

Writing Counterarguments Worksheet: Grade 5

15 questions in 3 parts: identify concerns, evaluate replies, and write two responses.

  • Grade: Grade 5
  • Standard: W.5.1
  • Questions: 15 questions: 13 multiple choice and 2 written responses in 3 parts
  • Pages: 3 worksheet pages and 3 answer key pages

It includes 13 questions for identifying concerns and judging replies, followed by two written responses. The answer key provides sample answers and lets teachers accept other relevant, respectful reasoning.5

Each one practices the same skill a different way, with its own answer key.

Recognize the SkillGrade 5Open
Guided CompletionGrade 5Open
Sentence PracticeGrade 5Open
Edit and CorrectGrade 5Open
Write and ApplyGrade 5Open

Worksheets on the skills that build on this one.

Opinion EssayRecognize the SkillGrade 5Open
Opinion EssayGuided CompletionGrade 5Open
Opinion EssaySentence PracticeGrade 5Open
Opinion EssayEdit and CorrectGrade 5Open
Persuasive EssayRecognize the SkillGrade 5Open
Persuasive EssayGuided CompletionGrade 5Open
Persuasive EssaySentence PracticeGrade 5Open
Persuasive EssayEdit and CorrectGrade 5Open

About this worksheet

This Grade 5 writing worksheet helps students recognize fair counterarguments and answer concerns with relevant reasons. Thirteen choice questions build toward two written responses about a class art day and a later school start. The work practices opinion writing aligned with CCSS W.5.1, and a separate answer key includes sample responses.

Aligned to W.5.1

What is a counterargument?

A counterargument is a reasonable view that challenges a writer’s claim. It should raise a concern about the proposal rather than repeat a supporting point or add an unrelated fact.

Question 1
  1. 1Claim: A school should add a garden.
  2. 2Concern: A garden may take time away from recess.
  3. 3The concern challenges the plan, so it is a counterargument.

How can a response stay respectful?

Name the concern fairly, then give a relevant reason or information in reply. “Some people worry about cost; families could share supplies” recognizes the concern and offers a connected answer.

What will students write?

The final two questions ask for a response about a class art day and a counterargument to a later school start. The key shows one possible answer for each; other reasoned responses can also fit.

How to use this worksheet

  1. 1Read the claim and identify what concern challenges it.
  2. 2Check whether a reply acknowledges the concern fairly.
  3. 3Use a relevant reason or evidence to answer it.
  4. 4For open responses, compare your idea with the sample and check that it stays respectful.

Common mistakes and quick fixes

The mistake

Calling an unrelated detail a counterargument.

The fix

Ask whether the detail challenges or raises a concern about the claim.

The mistake

Dismissing the other view.

The fix

Restate the concern in words its speaker would recognize.

The mistake

Giving a reply that does not answer the concern.

The fix

Add a relevant reason or information tied to that concern.

Common Core alignment

Children practice writing opinion responses with relevant reasons.

W.5.1Common Core · Grade 5

Answer opposing views with relevant reasons tied to an opinion.

On this sheet: The final responses ask students to state a fair opposing view and give a relevant reply that supports a position.

Show the official wording
Write opinion pieces on topics or texts, supporting a point of view with reasons and information.
W.5.1 on the standards site

What to practice next

Make more practice

Further reading

Questions parents and teachers ask

What is a counterargument?

A counterargument is a reasonable concern or opposing view about a claim. For example, someone may support a school garden while recognizing that it could take time away from recess. The first three questions ask students to distinguish a real concern from a supporting detail.

How should a writer answer an opposing view?

A writer can show that the concern is understood, then answer it with a relevant reason or piece of information. On this worksheet, sharing supplies answers a cost concern, while teacher guidance answers a concern about choosing books that are too difficult.

Are the written answers the only possible answers?

No. The answer key gives sample responses for questions 14 and 15, but other answers can work if they state a fair concern and answer it respectfully. Check that the response stays connected to the class art day or later start topic and gives a reason.

What makes an opposing view fair?

A fair opposing view raises a concern that someone could reasonably have about the claim. “A garden may take time away from recess” challenges the proposal; “students can observe plants” supports it instead. The worksheet asks children to notice that difference before writing.

How many questions are on the worksheet?

There are 15 questions in four parts: 13 multiple-choice questions and two written responses. The questions move from identifying concerns to judging replies and composing a response. Allow about 30 minutes, including time to plan the final answers.