About this worksheet
This free Grade 5 worksheet teaches students to recognize a counterargument: a reasonable concern that challenges an opinion. Classroom decisions about art, outdoor lunch, pets, and recess keep the examples concrete. Students choose four opposing concerns, label four concerns or responses, choose two direct responses, and write a concern with a reply about growing plants. The final pair practices supporting a position with a specific reason or detail under Common Core W.5.1b. The separate answer key gives fixed answers and two sample written responses.
Aligned to W.5.1b
How can students recognize a fair counterargument?
Start with the stated opinion, then look for a concern that would make someone hesitate to agree. For adding art time, the cost of supplies is relevant. Saying that art is enjoyable supports the opinion instead.
A counterargument deserves an accurate, respectful description. Students should name a possible problem rather than insult the people who hold a different view.
What makes a response address the concern?
A response works when its reason or detail answers the objection. If the concern is rain at an outdoor lunch, planning an indoor option answers it. Saying that picnics are fun leaves the weather concern unresolved.
- 1Question 8: Some students may worry about rainy days. → C
- 2Question 7: We could eat inside whenever rain is forecast. → R
- 3The response offers a plan for the exact weather concern.
How should students write the final concern and reply?
Question 11 asks for a reasonable concern about growing plants in class. Question 12 asks students to join that concern and a direct reply with but. Read the sentence as a pair of connected ideas: the reply should explain how to handle the concern.
If the concern is care during breaks, naming a volunteer who takes plants home is a relevant plan. If the concern is limited space, a response about a small windowsill container is a better match. Accept other coherent pairs.
How to use this worksheet
- 1Read each opinion before considering its possible objections.
- 2Choose the concern in Part A that challenges the stated position.
- 3In Part B, label the objection C and the attempt to address it R.
- 4In Part C, compare responses by asking which one addresses the exact concern.
- 5Write the plant concern, then join it to a specific reply with but. Compare the connection with the sample key.
Mistakes to discuss and fix
The mistake
Selecting “Art is enjoyable” as a counterargument to adding art time.
The fix
That supports the opinion. Look for a possible obstacle such as supply costs.
The mistake
Labeling the indoor lunch plan as another concern.
The fix
The plan tells how to handle rain, so it is a response to the concern.
The mistake
Answering a plant-care concern with “Plants look nice.”
The fix
Address care directly by explaining who could water the plants during breaks.
Common Core alignment
Support a response to an opposing concern with a relevant reason or detail.
On this sheet: Students distinguish concerns from responses and write a specific supporting reason or plan in their own reply.
Show the official wordingHide the official wording
Provide logically ordered reasons that are supported by facts and details.
What to practice next
Make more practice
Further reading
Questions parents and teachers ask
What is the difference between a counterargument and a response?
A counterargument raises a reasonable concern about an opinion, while a response addresses that concern. On this sheet, rain is a concern about outdoor lunch. Eating indoors when rain is forecast is a response. Ask students which sentence names a problem and which sentence offers a way to handle it.
Does a counterargument have to begin with “some people”?
No; a counterargument can be a statement or a question. “Who feeds it on breaks?” raises a concern about keeping a class pet. Part B uses “some families” and “some students” to make viewpoints clear, but students should identify the job of the sentence rather than memorize a phrase.
How should I check the final two written answers?
Read the concern and response together and check that the reply addresses the specific issue. In question 12, students join the ideas with but. For example, plants need water over breaks, but a volunteer could take them home. Accept other reasonable concerns paired with a relevant plan.
Can more than one response to a concern be reasonable?
Yes; real concerns can have several reasonable responses. The multiple-choice items offer one direct response beside choices that do not address the concern. The final writing task is open, so accept any clear plan or reason that fits the student’s concern rather than requiring the exact sample wording.
How can this recognition work help with an opinion paragraph?
Students can use a concern and response to strengthen a paragraph supporting a position. After finishing the sheet, ask them to state an opinion about classroom plants, give a reason, acknowledge their concern, and include their response. Read the paragraph aloud to check that the ideas follow a sensible order.






