About this worksheet
This Grade 5 printable gives students a passage about a school garden affected by runoff, then asks them to trace the problem, evaluate attempted solutions, and infer from evidence. The questions move from identifying details to explaining how several actions work together. The answer key is included on a separate page. It practices Common Core RI.5.1 by focusing on problem-and-solution structure.
Aligned to RI.5.1
How does problem and solution structure work?
A problem-and-solution text names a difficulty, explains what caused it, and describes one or more actions meant to improve the situation. The result shows whether those actions helped. Readers can mark each part as they go.
In this passage, rain carries soil into a school garden. Students try edging, observe its limits, then combine grasses, mulch, and a channel.
How can students use evidence to make an inference?
An inference combines a text detail with a sensible conclusion. Students should point to the words that support their thinking instead of guessing from a familiar situation.
- 1Question: Why did plastic edging fail to solve the whole problem?
- 2Evidence: Water pooled behind it and spilled over in one spot.
- 3Answer: The barrier did not guide all the water safely.
What does each part ask readers to do?
The first questions identify the runoff problem, its cause, and parts of the students’ plan. Later items connect details, infer why the plan worked, and apply the evidence to a blocked channel. Two written responses ask for a summary and a supported explanation.
How to use this worksheet
- 1Read the full passage once to learn the garden problem.
- 2Underline a detail that explains what caused the runoff.
- 3For each choice, return to the sentence that supports it.
- 4In the written responses, name both the problem and a relevant action.
- 5Check the key and revise any answer that is not supported by the passage.
Common mistakes and quick fixes
The mistake
Treating the first idea as the final solution.
The fix
Notice that the edging caused water to pool, then read what the students tried next.
The mistake
Choosing an inference with no passage evidence.
The fix
Point to the exact detail that makes the conclusion reasonable.
The mistake
Listing actions without connecting them to the problem.
The fix
Explain how roots, mulch, or the channel addresses runoff.
Common Core alignment
Students cite details from an informational passage when answering questions and drawing inferences.
Use accurate text details when answering questions and drawing inferences.
On this sheet: Students answer detail questions and use passage evidence to explain inferences.
Show the official wordingHide the official wording
Quote accurately from a text when explaining what the text says explicitly and when drawing inferences from the text.
What to practice next
Make more practice
Further reading
Questions parents and teachers ask
What is problem and solution text structure?
Text organized as problem and solution presents a difficulty and actions meant to address it. In this passage, runoff carries soil into a school garden, and students combine grasses, mulch, and a channel to manage it. Ask the student to point to a specific detail, explain how it supports the answer, and check the response against the separate key.
How many questions are on the worksheet?
There are 14 questions: eight multiple-choice items and six short answers. Students identify the runoff problem, trace the class’s responses, and support inferences with passage details. Ask the student to point to a specific detail, explain how it supports the answer, and check the response against the separate key.
What does the answer key include?
The answer key lists the correct choices and sample responses for short-answer items. For open responses, compare the student’s wording with the passage and accept a different answer when it is accurate and supported. Ask the student to point to a specific detail, explain how it supports the answer, and check the response against the separate key.
How should a student answer the written questions?
A strong response answers the question and names a relevant passage detail. For example, students can explain that runoff harmed seedlings by citing the sentence that says mud covered them. Ask the student to point to a specific detail, explain how it supports the answer, and check the response against the separate key.
Can this worksheet be used for inference practice?
Yes. Students infer why the edging did not solve the problem by connecting the detail about pooled water with the need for another approach. Other questions ask them to support conclusions with specific sentences. Ask the student to point to a specific detail, explain how it supports the answer, and check the response against the separate key.
How long does the worksheet take?
About 20 minutes is a useful estimate for reading the passage, answering the questions, and writing short responses. Students can return to the passage as needed to locate evidence. Ask the student to point to a specific detail, explain how it supports the answer, and check the response against the separate key.












