About this worksheet
This free printable worksheet gives Grade 5 students a short original story and eleven questions that check how closely they read it. In "Alex and Amanda's First Concert," two students practice a duet, and when Alex loses his place at the winter concert, Amanda helps them recover by listening. The story is Part A. Part B asks about the problem, a metaphor, a vocabulary word, the purpose of a detail and the theme. Part C sends students back to the story for a detail, a simile, the order of events and a piece of evidence. Part D asks for two written explanations. It practices Common Core RL.5.2 and RL.5.4, and a separate answer key gives every answer, with samples for the two written questions.
Aligned to RL.5.2 and RL.5.4
What is the story about, and what is it good for?
The story is about 230 words long and is split into four short paragraphs. Alex (piano) and Amanda (violin) rush their duet in practice. At the winter concert, Alex loses his place halfway through, and Amanda slows down and plays softly until he finds it again. It suits Grade 5 because it has a clear problem and solution, a teacher's piece of advice that has to be read as a figure of speech, and a theme that is shown in what the characters do.
Because the story is original, students cannot rely on having read it before. They have to read this one closely.
How do students figure out a word like faltered from the story?
Students use the sentences around an unfamiliar word. Faltered appears in "Alex's fingers faltered, and he lost his place. The piano fell silent." The next two sentences show what happened: he lost his place and the music stopped. That is the clue. Faltered means hesitated or stumbled.
A useful habit is to put each answer choice in the sentence and read it aloud. "Alex's fingers grew stronger" does not fit with a lost place and a silent piano.
- 1"Alex's fingers faltered, and he lost his place. The piano fell silent."
- 2Clues: he lost his place; the piano fell silent.
- 3Try "grew stronger": that does not fit a silent piano.
- 4Try "hesitated or stumbled": that fits losing your place.
- 5Answer: Hesitated or stumbled
How do students find a theme and support it?
A theme is the lesson a story shows, not a summary of what happens. To find it, students ask how the characters respond to the challenge. Here the problem is that Alex loses his place, and Amanda responds by slowing down and listening. That choice shows the theme in question 5, that good partners listen.
Part C turns to evidence. Question 6 asks which detail shows that Alex was nervous, and question 9 asks which sentence shows that Amanda stayed calm. Each answer is a detail students can find and point to in the story.
What do the written questions ask for?
Part D has two written answers: how Amanda helped the duet, and how the ending shows what Ms. Okafor meant when she called a duet a conversation. A good answer names what Amanda did (played softly and slowly, waited for Alex) and says why it helped. The answer key has a sample for each. Students' own wording will vary, so check for story details.
How to use this worksheet at home or in class
- 1Have your student read the story once for the sequence of events and once with a pencil, underlining anything that shows a feeling.
- 2Before answering, say in one sentence what the problem was and how it was solved.
- 3Do Part B (questions 1 to 5), then check the vocabulary and theme answers with the key before moving on.
- 4In Part C, have your student point to the sentence in the story that supports each answer.
- 5For Part D, ask for a full sentence and at least one detail, for example: "Amanda played softer, so Alex could find his place."
- 6Finish by asking, "What would have happened if Amanda had kept racing ahead?"
Common mistakes and quick fixes
The mistake
Taking "A duet is a conversation" literally and choosing "Players talk first" (question 2).
The fix
Ask what people do in a conversation besides talk. They listen and answer. Ms. Okafor's next sentence, "Listen before you speak," gives the clue.
The mistake
Retelling the plot instead of stating a theme, for example "Alex lost his place and Amanda helped."
The fix
Ask, "What lesson does the story teach?" A theme is a sentence about people, such as "Good partners listen," not an event.
The mistake
Writing an answer with no detail from the story, like "She was nice." (questions 10 and 11).
The fix
Give a sentence starter: "In the story, Amanda ___, so ___." The answer needs one thing she did and one result.
Common Core alignment
Most US states use the Common Core Reading standards or a close state version. These are the two Grade 5 literature standards this worksheet practices.
Find the lesson of a story from how the characters respond to a problem.
On this sheet: Question 5 asks for the theme, and question 10 asks how a character responded to a challenge.
Show the official wordingHide the official wording
Determine a theme of a story, drama, or poem from details in the text, including how characters in a story or drama respond to challenges or how the speaker in a poem reflects upon a topic; summarize the text.
Work out what a word, a metaphor and a simile mean as the story uses them.
On this sheet: Question 3 asks what faltered means, and questions 2 and 7 ask about a metaphor and a simile.
Show the official wordingHide the official wording
Determine the meaning of words and phrases as they are used in a text, including figurative language such as metaphors and similes.
What to practice next
Make more practice
Further reading
Questions parents and teachers ask
What reading skills does this worksheet practice?
It practices finding a theme, using context to work out a word, understanding a metaphor and a simile, and choosing text evidence. Part B asks about the story's problem, theme and vocabulary, Part C asks for supporting details, and Part D asks students to explain their thinking in writing.
What is the theme of Alex and Amanda's First Concert?
The theme is that good partners listen to each other. Amanda does not rush ahead when Alex loses his place. She plays softer and slower until he finds it, and Ms. Okafor says that is what a duet sounds like. The ending shows listening is what makes the music work.
What does faltered mean in this story?
Faltered means hesitated or stumbled. The sentence says Alex's fingers faltered and he lost his place, and then the piano fell silent. Those details show that his playing stopped. Students can check an answer by putting it in the sentence and reading it aloud to see if it fits.
What are the answers to the multiple-choice questions?
The answers are: 1, they raced each other; 2, players should listen; 3, hesitated or stumbled; 4, to start in step; 5, good partners listen; 6, he wiped his damp palms; 7, it guided Alex back; 8, Amanda played softer; and 9, she did not rush ahead.
How long is the story, and is it right for Grade 5?
The story is about 230 words in four short paragraphs, with a few figures of speech and a vocabulary word that must be worked out from context. That is a good length for Grade 5 independent reading. Students who struggle can read it aloud first, then answer the questions.
How should students answer the two written questions?
They should write a full sentence that says what a character did and why it mattered. For question 10, that might be: Amanda played softer and slower so Alex could find his place. The key gives a sample answer, but any answer with accurate story details can be correct.















