Skip to main content

Which grade are you exploring?

We'll open that grade's lessons. You can switch any time on the lessons page.

Not sure? Find your child's level with the free Grade Check

Grade 5 reading · Fact and opinion

Grade 5 Fact and Opinion: Read and Respond

Read a school garden passage, classify facts and opinions, locate evidence, and write a supported response in 14 questions.

  • Grade: Grade 5
  • Standard: CCSS RI.5.1
  • Questions: 14: multiple choice and one evidence-based written response
  • Pages: 3 worksheet pages and 3 answer key pages

Build on Grade 5 reading comprehension5

Each one practices the same skill a different way, with its own answer key.

Preview and VocabularyGrade 5Open
Main Idea and DetailsGrade 5Open
Sequence and StructureGrade 5Open
Inference and EvidenceGrade 5Open
Mixed Comprehension ChallengeGrade 5Open

Worksheets on the skills that build on this one.

Authors PurposePreview and VocabularyGrade 5Open
Authors PurposeMain Idea and DetailsGrade 5Open
Authors PurposeSequence and StructureGrade 5Open
Authors PurposeInference and EvidenceGrade 5Open
Cause EffectPreview and VocabularyGrade 5Open
Cause EffectMain Idea and DetailsGrade 5Open
Cause EffectSequence and StructureGrade 5Open
Cause EffectInference and EvidenceGrade 5Open
Compare ContrastPreview and VocabularyGrade 5Open
Compare ContrastMain Idea and DetailsGrade 5Open
Compare ContrastSequence and StructureGrade 5Open
Compare ContrastInference and EvidenceGrade 5Open

About this worksheet

This free Grade 5 reading-comprehension worksheet uses an original informational passage about a school garden. Students distinguish checkable details from opinions, answer questions about the passage, quote evidence, and write a brief opinion supported by a text detail. The evidence questions practice CCSS RI.5.1. The passage and 14 questions span three worksheet pages, with a separate answer key.

Aligned to RI.5.1

What does the passage say about the garden?

Maple School students plant vegetables and flowers in raised beds. The passage gives details that a reader can verify, such as the club’s meeting day and how often the cafeteria served garden lettuce. It also reports different opinions about the garden and recess.

  • 13 multiple-choice questions
  • 1 written response supported by a passage detail
  • A separate key with sample evidence-based response

How can you tell a fact from an opinion?

Ask whether records, observation, or another source could check the statement. “The club meets each Tuesday” can be checked against a schedule. “Fresh food tastes better” expresses a preference, so readers may disagree.

Worked example from Part B
  1. 1Question: Why might some students object to adding garden beds?
  2. 2Find the passage detail: “Some students say the beds take space from recess.”
  3. 3That sentence explains the objection.
  4. 4Answer: The beds take space from recess.

How should students use passage evidence?

Answer the question first, then find the sentence that supports the answer. For a fact, copy the detail accurately. For an opinion response, say what you think and connect it to a relevant fact from the passage.

What makes a strong written response?

A complete response states a clear view and includes evidence that relates to it. The answer key provides a sample, but students may support a different view with a correct detail from the passage.

How to read and respond

  1. 1Read the passage once to understand the school’s garden and the decision it faces.
  2. 2For each fact question, look for a detail that a record or observation could confirm.
  3. 3For opinion questions, find language that shows a preference or judgment.
  4. 4Return to the passage before answering short-response questions.
  5. 5Quote a relevant detail in the final response, then compare your reasoning with the sample key.

Fact-and-opinion checks

The mistake

Calling a statement an opinion because it is about a person.

The fix

Ask whether evidence could verify it; a meeting schedule is still a fact.

The mistake

Treating a preference as true for everyone.

The fix

Words such as better or wonderful often signal a judgment people can disagree about.

The mistake

Giving an opinion without passage support.

The fix

State your view, then quote or accurately name one detail that relates to it.

Common Core alignment

Students return to the passage to explain what it states and support their responses with accurate details.

RI.5.1Common Core · Grade 5

Quote accurately from the passage when explaining stated details and responses.

On this sheet: Questions 9–14 ask students to quote or use accurate passage details in their explanations and written response.

Show the official wording
Quote accurately from a text when explaining what the text says explicitly and when drawing inferences from the text.
RI.5.1 on the standards site

What to practice next

Further reading

Questions parents and teachers ask

What is the difference between a fact and an opinion?

A fact is a statement that can be checked with evidence, such as the garden club meeting each Tuesday. An opinion expresses a judgment or preference, such as saying fresh food tastes better. This passage includes both, and several questions ask students to explain which details can be verified.

What passage does the worksheet use?

The worksheet includes an original informational passage about fifth graders at Maple School growing vegetables and flowers. It describes the garden club, cafeteria salads, and a possible plan to add two beds. Students use those details to answer 14 questions across three worksheet pages.

How should a student answer a fact question?

Return to the passage and locate the sentence that gives the detail. Copy the words accurately when a question asks for a quotation. This sheet uses multiple choice for the fact and opinion checks and ends with a short written response; the key supplies its sample answer.

Can students have different answers to the last question?

Yes. Students may support either view about adding beds if they clearly state an opinion and connect it to a relevant detail from the passage. For example, they could refer to students recording plant growth or to the field’s use for recess. The key shows one sample response.

Does this page include an answer key?

Yes. The answer key follows the worksheet pages and marks each correct choice. It also gives a sample for the final written response, which asks students to state an opinion and quote a passage detail. A teacher or parent can compare the detail with the passage.