Skip to main content

Which grade are you exploring?

We'll open that grade's lessons. You can switch any time on the lessons page.

Not sure? Find your child's level with the free Grade Check

Grade 5 reading · Facts & Opinions

Fact and Opinion Worksheet: Mixed Comprehension Challenge

Classify facts and opinions, then judge what a two-week lunch trial’s evidence can support.

  • Grade: Grade 5
  • Standard: RI.5.8
  • Questions: 14 questions: 8 fact-or-opinion classifications and 6 evidence responses
  • Pages: 4 worksheet pages and 4 answer key pages

More practice after facts & opinions5

Each one practices the same skill a different way, with its own answer key.

Preview and VocabularyGrade 5Open
Main Idea and DetailsGrade 5Open
Sequence and StructureGrade 5Open
Inference and EvidenceGrade 5Open
Written ResponseGrade 5Open

Worksheets on the skills that build on this one.

Authors PurposePreview and VocabularyGrade 5Open
Authors PurposeMain Idea and DetailsGrade 5Open
Authors PurposeSequence and StructureGrade 5Open
Authors PurposeInference and EvidenceGrade 5Open
Main IdeaPreview and VocabularyGrade 5Open
Main IdeaMain Idea and DetailsGrade 5Open
Main IdeaSequence and StructureGrade 5Open
Main IdeaInference and EvidenceGrade 5Open
Conclusions InferencesPreview and VocabularyGrade 5Open
Conclusions InferencesMain Idea and DetailsGrade 5Open
Conclusions InferencesSequence and StructureGrade 5Open
Conclusions InferencesInference and EvidenceGrade 5Open

About this worksheet

This Grade 5 worksheet uses an original article about a school lunch trial. Students classify statements as facts or opinions, identify evidence for a claim, and explain what the trial can and cannot show. The questions build close reading by asking readers to connect an author’s point with reasons and evidence, as described in RI.5.8. The answer key gives classifications and sample evidence-based responses.

Aligned to RI.5.8

What skill does this page practice?

This page practices facts & opinions with the text and tasks printed on the sheet.

How can a reader build a strong answer?

Read the whole prompt, find the detail or clue that answers it, and check that your response fits the question.

Worked example (question 9)
  1. 1The count fell from 19 on the first Tuesday to 8 on the second Thursday.
  2. 2That supports Jalen’s view for the two recorded days.
  3. 3The short trial still leaves unanswered questions.

What will children do on the worksheet?

The worksheet has 14 questions. The answer key follows the same order and gives sample wording for open responses.

How to use this worksheet

  1. 1Read the article once to follow the lunch proposal and trial.
  2. 2Classify each statement by deciding whether it can be checked or gives a judgment.
  3. 3For evidence questions, return to the exact sentence with the numbers or limitation.
  4. 4Explain how a detail supports a point, using a complete sentence.
  5. 5Use the key to compare the idea; accurate wording may differ.

Common mistakes and quick fixes

The mistake

Treating a prediction or preference as a recorded fact.

The fix

Reread the prompt, find the relevant detail, and revise the response so it answers the question clearly.

The mistake

Calling any number proof of a broad conclusion.

The fix

Reread the prompt, find the relevant detail, and revise the response so it answers the question clearly.

The mistake

Giving an opinion without pointing to the passage.

The fix

Reread the prompt, find the relevant detail, and revise the response so it answers the question clearly.

Common Core alignment

This activity connects close reading and written responses to a specific English language arts standard.

RI.5.8Common Core · Grade 5

Identify reasons and evidence an author uses to support points.

On this sheet: Readers separate verifiable statements from judgments, then locate evidence supporting an author’s point.

Show the official wording
Explain how an author uses reasons and evidence to support particular points in a text, identifying which reasons and evidence support which point(s).
RI.5.8 on the standards site

What to practice next

Make more practice

Further reading

Questions parents and teachers ask

Why is “perfect lunch length” an opinion?

“Perfect” tells what someone thinks is best; it cannot be checked in the same way as the recorded twenty-minute schedule. The worksheet asks children to classify statements and explain what the article actually shows. Question 6 uses a similar judgment word, “perfect,” to signal an opinion.

Does the article say that every student wants a longer lunch?

No. It reports that 78 of 120 surveyed students wanted more time for eating or talking. It also explains that the survey did not separate lunch groups, so its results do not describe every student’s preference. That limitation narrows what the survey can show about the whole school.

What evidence supports Jalen’s view?

The number of students still eating after the bell fell from 19 on the first Tuesday to 8 on the second Thursday. Those are two recorded observations, which support his view while leaving questions about the rest of the school week.

Why is the principal cautious about the trial?

The change happened on only two days, and the school did not measure how quickly classes began afterward. Children use those limits to explain why promising numbers do not settle the question. Question 10 asks children to explain both limits in a complete sentence.

What does the answer key include?

It lists the fact-or-opinion classification for each of the first eight statements and sample responses for the six evidence questions. For example, the key compares the two after-bell counts and names the survey’s lunch-group limitation. Those references point children back to specific article details.

How long does this worksheet take?

Plan about 25 minutes to read the article, complete 14 questions, and review the key. Allow more time if the child discusses what evidence would make the school’s decision stronger. The key is a useful final check after the reading and writing are complete.